MedTech Expert Explains Disinfection Technology Efficacy Validation | Pressure Tested

What are disinfection technologies, and how do you prove they work?

What does BS 8628 require, and what must manufacturers demonstrate before bringing UVC devices to market?

Enrico Allegra, Director of Operations at Test Labs, returns for his second Pressure Tested to explore disinfection technologies, how their efficacy is tested, and the challenges manufacturers face when validating their devices.

He explains the differences between UVC and other disinfection technologies, which wavelengths are most effective, and the factors that influence performance. He also breaks down BS 8628 and its testing requirements, including worst-case conditions and microbiological testing. Along the way, he explores what manufacturers need to demonstrate for FDA and MDR submissions, why material compatibility matters, what a complete testing package involves, and how long testing typically takes. Enrico also shares practical advice for UVC developers, highlighting why design decisions and early testing can make a significant difference to successful validation.

Video Transcript

Hello. My name is Enrico Allegra, Director of Operations at Test Labs. This is the second episode of Pressure Tested, a special edition on disinfection technologies.

What is a disinfection technology?
So in a healthcare system, and also this can expand to other areas, but ultimately is a device, ultimately automated, which is able to decontaminate either a space or a specific medical device, for example. So it could be anything between a tower-like system UVC device to a self-contained container like a box, which would be specific for a medical device, such as, for example, endoscopes or any probes, for example, that needs to be decontaminated.

What technology do you test the most?
So we have a range of technology comes to our lab. Again, majority could be UVC devices. We also test also fogging devices, so something like hydrogen peroxide. But within the UVC world, again, there’s quite a few types. Again, you have surface decontamination devices, so again, what we call tower devices. They normally, it’s something that could be automated, so they may move around like your Roomba. You map a space and then it’s able to walk, or the static device where you would place them into a room and they would decontaminate against specific surfaces. At the same time, we test medical device specific decontamination devices. So it could be a self-contained UVC, for example, devices which is specifically designed for specific endoscopes or, again, any specific medical devices. But the range quite vary, therefore, we tend to then work with the manufacturer to adapt the testing methodology to make sure we meet their requirements.

What makes you an expert on disinfection technologies?
disinfection technologies? It’s a good point. You caught me out there. But, ultimately, I’ve been in the decontamination environment for the last decade. I was part of a company sort of actively sort of developing new decontamination technology from, again, hydrogen peroxide, so from fogging to UVC technologies. I was part of the first laboratory in the United Kingdom, and as far as I’m aware, in Europe, to gain ISO/IEC 17025 accreditation for BS8628 standard, which is the only recognised standard so far, at least, for UVC technologies. So I feel like I’ve done a lot of groundwork. I do understand how the technology works. Ultimately, my background is microbiology, so I understand how the interaction with a molecular level with bacteria and how the technologies need to advance, right, to make sure they achieve the right decontamination. But as I said, I’ve been in this environment for a long time. I’ve tested a lot of different devices coming through our lab. Again, being the only laboratory with a ISO/IEC 17025 accreditation sort of gives us that edge where everybody wants to come through here to get their technology tested. So I feel like I graduated into the expert category, and that’s why I’m here and being pressure tested.

What is BS 8628 and what does it test?
In 2022, I want to say, BSI released a new standard, BS8628. So I think the whole idea of releasing the standard was to catch up with technologies moving quite far and quite fast. And the idea is, straight after COVID, a lot of UVC devices sort of entered the market. There were a lot of claims, a lot of wild claims sometimes. But ultimately, there wasn’t a real standardised way of testing them, how they perform in real life. BS8628 gave that platform, sort of that framework to make sure all the UVC devices can now be tested under the same kind of thresholds and same challenges. So ultimately, it’s a disinfection or decontamination standard specifically designed for UVC devices. And again, it could be it’s designed for either whole room decontamination, so for surface level decontamination, but it has a category where it specifically talks about self-contained UVC devices that are intended for medical device specific application. Again, like an endoscopy for example, an endoscope or any other devices or any probes, for example, that need disinfection. So ultimately, this standard gave a good sort of starting point for all the companies to be able to say, “Hey, I’ve got my device. It’s now been tested against an international sort of recognised now standard, and I can say that my UVC device has achieved the right level of efficacy.” So the standard ultimately talks about efficacy, so and how your decontamination technology is able to reduce contamination up to a log 5 reduction in, for example, bacteria, etc.. But ultimately, this is what kind of defined the standards.

What are the requirements of BS 8628?
So BS8628, as I mentioned, is standard for UVC devices. Requirements are very similar to other disinfectant standards. So the disinfectant word is very well-defined. Again, we’ve been using disinfectant for a long time. Normally, they come into spray, liquids, wipes. But lately, a lot of this technology like UVC now is slightly different, but the framework was built around the disinfectant. So the requirements of BS8628 are very similar to a, what would be, for example, for a wipe or for a spray. So normally you have to achieve a log reduction in certain categories of microorganisms. So normally they’re split into bacteria, yeast, fungi, spores, mycobacteria, etc.. So starting from the top, we’ve got bacteria. You need to achieve a log 5 reduction. And yeast, for example, you need to achieve a log 4 reduction. These two categories give you what is called the minimum requirements to be able to claim compliance with the standard. Then you have further categories, which is kind of almost like add-on to make sure your device has a better marketing claim or better efficacy. So fungicidal, where you would have to add Aspergillus brasiliensis, for example, claim, and that’s a log 4, and all the way down to, for example, mycobacteria. But these are normally the requirements to be able to claim compliance to the standard.

Which UVC wavelengths are effective?
Good question, and I think I’m going to get assaulted for this probably. However, there’s a lot of studies being done on this. If we go down to UV in general, without taking into consideration UVB and UVA, which is more like sunlight, etc.. But in the UVC realm, we start from the wavelength of 220, let’s say, all the way to around sort of 280. Amongst this sort of range, at least there’s been a lot of studies proving that around the 254 range seems to have the best bactericidal efficacy in terms of how the light is absorbed into the actual membrane of bacteria. So a lot of studies, and this goes down almost to a molecular level, how in fact the light interacts with the microorganism and how it breaks down the DNA, etc.. Having said so, 254 is definitely not the only one. There’s been a lot of testing done with LED light. So LED UVC tends to be between 260 and 270 nanometers in wavelength. That has been proven incredibly effective. And the amazing thing about LED is that the technology behind LED is improving each year. And every time I get a new device, actually, they tend to perform a lot better than what they used to. Where the 254 nanometers wavelength sometimes it’s sort of, I wouldn’t say it’s an old technology, but it hasn’t fully evolved as much as LED, and therefore they tend to be… It’s very little innovation around those. And at the same time, there’s been some research which has show a level of efficacy with a lower spectrum, so under 220 nanometers, which is sometimes referred as far UVC. personally, I’ve not seen many devices performing as well around that range. Definitely, I would say between the 250 and 270, there’s a much better efficacy. But ultimately, that’s dependent on the device configuration. So you could get an amazing efficacy even at lower end. It kind of depends on your design and how, if you sort of create your system in a way that is able to sort of maximise the performance of the lamps, basically.

What affects UVC efficacy?
Which I guess basically means What helps efficacy of UV devices? It’s a lot of things. So I’ve talked a little bit about wavelength. So wavelength definitely has a big impact. So choosing your starting wavelength will also dictate some of your design features, obviously. But choosing whether or not you’re going to use mercury lamps, kind of lamps, amalgam lamps. There’s all sorts of different lamps out there, all the way to using LED UV, which again, very different scenario. So you’re choosing your starting point, your wavelength is step one of giving you a better chance for better efficacy. But ultimately, design feature is the major thing. So you have to think that UV ultimately is linked to physics, obviously. So radiation, so incident light sometimes, or direct contact with the surface needs to be decontaminated will give you the best chance. So when you, for example, are designing a tower device for surface decontamination, I think will give you a better chance to have lamps, for example, that are surrounding your device. Make sure you have a more 365 degree coverage. Make sure your angle of incidence is optimised for flat surfaces, for example. But at the same time, if reflection can help as well, it’s been proven. So if you’re performing or creating new devices with self-contained UVC, again, there’s a lot of them out there where they tend to have reflective surfaces where they’re trying to maximise, again, as I said, trying to maximise the power and the performance of your features. So all of these things can influence the efficacy and the final effectiveness of your device.

What is the BS 8628 test set-up?
The setup is actually pretty neat, pretty cool. Again, normally these tests are performed in testing chambers. The testing chamber itself, imagine, is a container, obviously, sort of chamber where, and normally the first requirement is you need to blackout your chamber. And by blackout I mean, imagine, normally these chambers are built out of stainless steel, for example, walls and floors and ceiling. Stainless steel could reflect UV lights. So again, the standard is telling you trying to black it out. Normally, it should be like a matte black fabric that surrounds the chamber that avoids any reflection. So imagine it’s almost a worst-case scenario testing. So that’s step one for your setup. Then there’s a lot of specific guidance on the standard of how you need to place your device. So your device should be placed two meters away from your challenge, the challenge being your bacteria, your yeast, or whatever you’re obviously testing against. And normally, your challenge has to be placed over, again, a black matte surface. Again, two meters away from your UV device, and then on a flat surface. So imagine your device is now trying to hit a flat surface rather than facing the challenge. So again, this increases the difficulties in a way of achieving the efficacy, and it has to be placed two meters away at one meter’s height. There’s a little bit of leeway there. I think it’s between one and 1.2 meters that you can play with. But that kind of the standards, again, and the whole point of the standard is to give that threshold, give that sort of benchmark to all the tests, to all the technology out there to be tested in the same way. So normally, this is the setup. So it’s a very dark environment. We have a couple chambers here, got 12 cubic meters, 65 cubic meters, so it can get quite dark there. But the idea is you’ll have the device sort of being away from source and being tested. It’s almost this worst-case location. There are a couple of instances where if you have a self-contained box, the setup obviously can’t quite meet that, so you’re going to have to rearrange slightly. But at the same time, we work with the manufacturer trying to understand what is their claim from that box, and then we have to place the challenge maybe in a slightly different place. Again, it will be difficult to place two meters away, but we’re trying to follow as much as possible the 8628 guidance and setup, sort of guidelines in a way. Okay,

Can my UVC robot move during the test?
Good question. Well, let’s say no. Let’s start with a no, but hopefully we can get there. However, the standard was written one way or another, obviously it was 2022, UVC device was sort of coming into play, and there was loads of technology being developed, and the standard was written for static room decontamination technology. So the idea is that although your device, in a way, unique selling point could be the fact that it can move really close to the surface and it will map out a room, and therefore, we can move around achieving better efficacy. The standard is trying to move away from what’s the best way of testing your devices to what’s the worst case for your device. So again, during the test, we can’t move your device unfortunately. So the device has to be static, again, two meters away from the challenge. And again, that would give every single device being tested under the standard the same benchmark, i.e., you can’t maximise some of this testing to make sure your device has a better chance. Again, that’s the whole point of standards. Everything is tested against the same setup. So ultimately, you cannot. What we could do, though, it’s slightly change that setup and maybe what we call base a study around 8628. We wouldn’t be able to fully call compliance against the standard, but we can test for real case scenarios where if your device does move around a chamber, we can sort of create a study designed that way where your device can move around and have a better efficacy. For example, 10 centimetres away from a surface or 20 centimetres away, and we can set up all these tests. The only thing is we wouldn’t be able to then claim compliance to the standard, but again, we will base all the testing according to that testing setup.

Can UVC be used for sterilisation?
It’s a good point, and I’ll give you possibly my personal opinion, which is possibly yes. And I say possibly because there are not real standards out there regarding UVC sterilisation. Do I think, can UVC achieve sterilisation? Yes, it possibly could. It probably will have to be tested in a similar way as any sterilisation devices out there. I think at the moment it’s difficult and there are a lot of challenges with UVC in terms of shadowing, for example, and whether or not you can achieve sterilisation everywhere in that device. But the idea is that at the moment, there are not really standards supporting the use of UVC as a sterilisation technology, more like a decontamination or high-level disinfection. But the technology is moving incredibly fast. I do think LED, for example, is moving at a very fast pace. LED technology and UVC, where there’s a lot less power output out there and giving you a lot more efficacy, in a way, a better dose. And I think with those kind of parameters, you can achieve sterilisation level. If nothing is stopping any manufacturer out there, by the way, to validate their product as sterilisation, it’s just that not being many standards out there, it can be challenging. But there are a lot of things you can do to prove that. But as I said, for the moment, I think the most common use is decontamination. But I do think in the future, there could be a lot of devices where they could go all the way to sterilisation. Again, that would give a lot of benefits to a lot of devices that are not compatible with steam or hydrogen peroxide or ethylene oxide, etc.. So there’s definitely a chance for UVC to get into that place. Next question. It’s going to make me chuckle already. ”

I have a lot of internal testing data. Can I use it to claim compliance?
You could. You could give it a go. it’s internal testing data, I’m assuming it probably refers to more theoretical. So from a physics point of view, I guess you can work out dosage and irradiations level and distances, etc., and trying to work out what’s my dose hitting a certain surface, i.e., then can I get a log reduction? And there’s a lot of research been done out there, a lot of published papers sort of stating specific dosage for specific organism. What I found with my experience is that a lot of the dosage don’t really translate in real-world data. So therefore, if you’re basing your entire design on dosage and radiation data only, chances are you’re going to have a difficult time trying to prove that you can achieve a certain log reduction in a certain timeframe. So I wouldn’t recommend to use that data. I would definitely recommend to get some at least microbiological data to try test it out to make sure that those you think should achieve the right efficacy is actually getting you there. And the standard itself, 8628, does add a lot of other challenges. So it adds things like soil condition and additional soil to your organism, which can impact that dose itself and the exposure time. So yeah, make sure you pair that data as you’re doing your design with some initial preliminary microbiological data, and I think that will give a much better chance in the long run. ”

Have you tested UVC devices for FDA submission?
Yes. We’ve been quite lucky. our lab, we are probably the only one so far with ISO/IEC 17025 accreditation under 8628. By doing so, we are able to almost get loads of inquiries and loads of devices coming through our laboratory. A lot of them also went through FDA because, again, we’re able to help them with, and we had a lot of knowledge on that, so we’re able to then support them. And ultimately, a lot of these submissions that were done, they were performed under 8628, obviously preliminary. So that will give the manufacturers immediate data on preclinical use, i.e., does my device or the intended use, in a way, can I prove that my device is intended to disinfect, does it actually disinfect? So we immediately support on that front. There’s a lot of other things that needs to be done to support the full FDA submission, but so far we’ve been pretty good and pretty successful on this. So quite a few clients have gone through that, and they haven’t had any problem. Most of them now, to be fair, are based on predicate device, so it’s not de novo anymore. I think there’s a clear roadmap to how to get there in a way. So we’re more than happy to be able to help clients during that submission journey. ”

What does the FDA want to see for a successful submission?
there’s a lot of data that needs to go through, but ultimately, it’s a medical device, so most of the time it follows a pattern. Right? So ultimately, you have to prove that the performance requirements are met. So does your UVC device achieve what it’s intended to do? So decontaminate spaces or specific devices. Is it safe? So is it safe to use, and can you have an impact on the surroundings? So, normally what we call biocompatibility, for example. Does it release anything somehow that can affect its biocompatibility claims? So these are the three main areas. When you break it down, so area one, again, decontamination. You can claim it by performing BS 8628, for example, or real simulated use testing, where you would soil a device, for example, expose it to your UV process and make sure it’s achieved the right efficacy. Safety normally around, for example, things like does it have sensor, for example? If someone were to enter a room while a disinfection is happening, will it stop automatically? Is the electrical safe? So 60601, for example. Can you claim electrical safety to make sure it’s all compliant to that? And step three will be your biocompatibility. So although it’s a radiation, you wouldn’t expect residual because again, it’s not chemical disinfection. But the idea is there’s two main points that UVC could create. One, there could be a chance where it creates ozone and releases ozone into the air, and is the ozone level too high, for example? So you need to prove that you don’t do that, or any other gases that may have problems. And if by any chance you interact with the surface of a medical device, for example, are you somehow impacting it and therefore creating a reaction where eventually you may make that device not biocompatible anymore, or may create layers of residual because somehow you are affecting the plastics, etc.. So if you’re able to then prove these three areas, then you probably would’ve answered all the questions from FDA, and it’s a very straightforward path to go through your submission.

Do I need to test efficacy on actual medical devices?
I’m assuming this question also relates very specifically to self-contained UVC devices, where again, they are claiming they can actually decontaminate a medical device. I think the good starting point is to maybe start with coupons, with tokens, etc., so that you can prove efficacy and general effectiveness of your device. But ultimately, if you’re going to claim that you can decontaminate specific devices, you should be able to then prove that and back it up with some data. So yes, and again, we work with many companies where we’ve done it, where they were able then to test with specific devices. And so my ultimate answer is yes, you need to have that data to back it up. And again, the major question also from my point of view and in general from notified bodies from FDA is, are you impacting the devices at all? Are you actually compatible with that device? Are you affecting their performance after you decontaminate it? So I think it’s really important to have that data to prove that you don’t have a worsening impact on the medical device that you’re trying to test, and you’re also able to claim efficacy to those specific areas. For example, worst-case areas from each specific medical device.

Our submission got stuck with the FDA due to a lack of compatibility data. What should we do?
obviously, without having more information, my understanding is that you’re going through your submission, you probably submit a lot of data on efficacy, etc., but you may have not shown that your UV device is compatible with certain specific medical devices, for example. So again, are you compatible with the device you intended to decontaminate? And that normally means a couple of things. So are you affecting the surface? So is that surface being somehow affected by it, and therefore the possible performance? Or it could simply be are you compatible if you decontaminate a space, for example, anything like that. Are you compatible with your surrounding materials? So you should have data to prove that the use of UV, for example, for a prolonged time, for repeated cycles, for repeated uses, does not impact negatively either a medical device or a surface or specific materials that you’re likely to encounter in the right field. So then my suggestion would be you should then set up a study where either we then test specific medical devices or a range of surfaces, etc., that can prove compatibility or material compatibility of UVC devices with those specific surfaces.

What do we do with UVC and MDR?
The submission is very similar to any other medical devices. Again, it does depend on your final claims. So you will get your first classification, most likely either going to be a Class 2a or Class 2b if you’re intended to use your device for decontaminating a certain specific instrument, or if you’re simply decontaminating surface level. So if it’s, again, a whole room decontamination device or if it’s a specific medical device. So once your classification is set, then you can go down the classic route of your technical files. You start building your technical file. So again, normally you would have very similar things, so with any other medical devices from you need to prove your GSPR, so your general safety and performance requirements. So is my device safe? So electrical safety, biocompatibility, material compatibility, and is my device performing as intended? So that would be efficacy, real data efficacy, simulated user efficacy. So once you’re able to then build all the testing data behind it into your technical file, get all the right documentation, then you’ll be able to go through the MDR without any problems.

What is the full test package for UVC technology?
I think I will break it down into, always go into three main categories. Right? So we have efficacy data. So make sure, again, your device does what it’s intended to do. We’ve got safety data, and then we’ve got material compatibility data. In the first set, so you got the efficacy side. Again, normally you should have two sets of data, one performing what we call with preclinical testing, for example, using coupons, using tokens, for example, inoculated, and the device tested at the worst case possible. But then also with simulated data, so a simulated use environment where your device is much more similar to set up how you will be using it in the real world. Then you’ve got your safety. Again, safety spans from electrical, from biocompatibility, and again, how safe is your device to be used. But again, it’s things like safety features, etc.. So do I have a sensor? Do I have emergency stop, etc.? And then you’ve got compatibility. So is, again, the UV device compatible with certain materials, with certain processes, and how many processes can I perform on certain surfaces or certain devices? So that I would call the full package. So once you’re able to reply, there’s a lot of nuances, obviously, and a lot of testing within each one of these. But that is something that we normally sell as one big package to UVC devices that want to go through either MDR or FDA, and so far there’s been no problems with that. So we know that this has been accepted, and there’ll be absolutely no issues basically going through your submission.

How long does it take to do all the testing?
normally, again, there’s a lot of testing to be done. And again, it depends. You might have already some testing done, but I reckon, efficacy testing can take anything between three to six weeks, depending on how many organisms we need to test, how many surfaces, etc., you want to claim efficacy against. Compatibility, again, it does depend a little bit on material compatibility. It depends a little bit on claims. So how long is your cycle, for example, and then how many reprocessing cycles we want to replicate. Again, your UV device may be an ultimate step of a pre-cleaning or something else. So when you’re, for example, creating a material compatibility study against a specific medical device, when we’re doing that sort of reprocessing, it may take a little bit longer. So that could take, again, anything between three to six weeks as well. A lot of these things can be done in parallel, by the way. So I reckon it does depend on the device, and it does depend on how many claims you have with that device. But anything between, I would say, three to six weeks will be a general kind of giveaway. But then normally we work really closely with the manufacturer to make sure if there’s any deadline or any submission, obviously, requirements that we manage to hit that. But that’s what I would say how long it would take for the full testing compatibility. Okay, next question is very commercial.

How much does it cost to get all of this done?
It goes without saying, I’m a scientist, I’m allowed to say it depends. However, it does depend on how many tests you need to do, how many claims you have, sometimes how many devices you have. So if you create a portfolio of different sizes or different configurations of your device, you might have to test all of them if they’re significantly different. But I think ultimately what I say to a lot of manufacturers is the ability of not being able to sell in certain markets, the delays into trying to pick, for example, multiple quotes or trying to go through that process of trying to save as much money with justifications, etc., to avoid certain testing, sometimes it may result in a bigger expenditure at the end of the day. Because if you get pushback from notified body or FDA, it may end up costing you more than having to do all the testing themselves. So my recommendation is make sure you create your plan properly with your testing lab. Make sure you tick all the boxes. And the budget itself, it could be, I would say anything, I would say between, whatever, 20 to 50K. The idea is it does depend. So we’re here to help ultimately, and then we can go through the submission with you.

What advice would you give to UVC developers?
design is key. Make sure when you’re designing it, you don’t just look how good it looks, but you’re thinking about, again, angle of incidence, what sort of wavelength of lights you’re going to use, again, which UV lamps you’re going to use, whether or not it’s going to be LED, and especially what’s your final application. And if you can understand that and how quickly you want to achieve your efficacy, for example, then you can build all those things into your design. After that, my second-biggest message is do start testing as early as possible. As soon as you get your first prototype, do some basic microbiological testing almost to prove that you’re going into the right direction. So if you’re able to start from the beginning in your design, do take all these things into consideration and make sure you’re going into that design process alongside with some testing data that is supporting the fact that you are onto the right track. Again, if you do all these things together, it’s most likely is once you got to your final prototype or to your initial pre-market phase, you most likely have a better chance to pass all the final testing or the various final compliance testing. So make sure, yeah, you’re taking into consideration design to its intended use, and you get testing alongside that along the way to make sure you’re going into the right path.

I’m Enrico Allegra, my second pressure test video just finished. Very interesting topic. It’s very close to my heart. I guess that’s why I’ve been called as the expert. It was a very interesting question about the cost. Look- Things can change, things can happen. However, do get in touch. I’m more than happy to sort of help you through your submission pathways and look forward, to be fair, to the next “Pressure Test” video.

Get It Done, With Certainty.

Contact us about your testing requirements, we aim to respond the same day.

Get resources & industry updates direct to your inbox

We’ll email you 1-2 times a week at the maximum and never share your information

Outlook, the publishing medtech platform with over 100,000 annual readers.

Contact Us: